EXCLUSIVE: Finger of suspicion hangs over convictions

A nationwide review is under way after hundreds of cases were put in jeopardy amid fears unauthorised police staff were routinely taking DNA and fingerprint samples.

Experts warn serious crimes could go unpunished as a result of the apparent blunder.

Leading defence QC Donald Findlay said convictions could be reviewed if the Police Scotland internal investigation finds evidence of malpractice.

The issue came to light after The Courier obtained an email ordering all police staff at stations in Dundee and Arbroath to stop custody duties immediately.

Labour MSP Graeme Pearson warned the implications could be devastating if it is found workers did not have the appropriate authority.

Custody division commander Chief Superintendent Ciorstan Shearer said the force is “actively seeking clarification” from partners, understood to include the Crown Office, about the roles and responsibilities of Scottish custody centre staff.

She added she was “confident there is no impact on service provision” while the investigation is ongoing.

For Kieran Andrews’ exclusive report, and full reaction, see Thursday’s Courier or try our digital edition.