Fife, known for its picturesque coastline, charming villages, and rich history, also boasts a culinary gem that has earned a reputation far and wide: its fish and chips.
From the award-winning establishments in Anstruther to the top quality chippers in St Andrews, Fife has long been home to some of Scotland’s finest seafood.
But on a recent trip to Dunfermline, I discovered a contender for the title of the best fish and chip shop in Fife: Jim Jack’s Fish & Chips.
Locals rave about it, but does it live up to the hype?
I set out to find out with my daughter and cousin’s family to see if this chipper could possibly challenge the established titans of the region.
The contenders are…
Fife is home to a proud fish and chip tradition, and the competition is fierce.
The famed Wee Chippie and Anstruther Fish Bar, for instance, have garnered numerous awards for impeccable quality and consistency, making them a must-visit for any self-respecting fish and chips enthusiast.
Then there’s Cromar’s in St Andrews, which is equally renowned for its award-winning, perfectly battered haddock and legendary chips.
But could Jim Jack’s in Dunfermline, a relative newcomer in the eyes of the wider Fife fish-and-chip community, stand shoulder to shoulder with these heavyweights?
A Sunday outing to Jim Jack’s
I’m a big fan a decent fish and chips, having tasted my way through some of the best chippers in the country, but I wanted to see for myself why Jim Jack’s has such a loyal following.
So, on a Sunday afternoon, I took my daughter and cousin’s family along to experience what the fuss was all about.
We chose to visit on one of Jim Jack’s two gluten-free days, a key selling point for those who need a safe and delicious alternative to traditional battered fish.
Despite Dunfermline having no shortage of fish and chips shops, Jim Jack’s is by far the most popular.
We arrived right when the restaurant opened at 4pm, as we’d been advised that the venue fills up fast.
Diners queuing before it even opened
And sure enough, as we walked up to the door, a line had already formed, snaking down the street with eager customers looking for their chippie fix.
The exterior of the shop isn’t much to look at, but don’t let that fool you. Inside, it’s warm and welcoming, with a simple, cosy interior and plenty of seating for diners.
The staff are welcoming, offering a relaxed, family-friendly vibe, which made the experience even more enjoyable.
As someone who appreciates a good traditional chippy with seating for high teas and a proper sit-down meal, I was pleased to see Jim Jack’s had embraced this model.
The menu offered all the expected delights of a classic fish and chips shop: haddock suppers, battered sausages, and of course, a range of kid-friendly options.
Mini macaroni cheese kept toddler busy
My daughter, Lily, opted for the macaroni cheese (£4.50) and mini pizza (£1.40).
For us adults, we went for a haddock suppers (£11.95), battered sausage supper (£7.20), bacon and cheese burger (£11.90), a half pizza supper (£7.90) and a chips and cheese (£4.95).
And I got the gluten-free fish and chips (£12.90) – something that isn’t always easy to find elsewhere in the area.
When our food arrived, I was immediately impressed by the speed of service, despite the busy takeaway counter and the bustling dining room.
Everything was piping hot and wonderfully fresh.
The haddock was perfectly battered – light, crispy, and not at all greasy. It flaked beautifully and the chunky, golden chips were delicious.
Gluten-free batter done right
Often, gluten-free batter can be too thick or a bit soggy, but Jim Jack’s nailed the balance, offering a crispy coating that was just a bit thicker than the usual batter.
A side of mushy peas, which I consider a vital part of any fish supper, was rich and tasty.
It wasn’t the watery mess that some other shops serve up, but thick and satisfying – exactly how it should be.
The battered sausages were hearty and well-cooked, encased in a perfectly crispy batter.
The kids devoured their meals, and Lily gave the macaroni cheese a thumbs-up, even though she wasn’t overly keen on the pizza (but I suspect the lively atmosphere may have distracted her).
How does Jim Jack’s compare to others?
Having recently enjoyed a fantastic gluten-free fish supper at The Wee Chippie in Anstruther, I couldn’t help but make comparisons.
While Jim Jack’s came close, it didn’t quite dethrone the iconic fish and chip shop on the east coast. The Wee Chippie’s fish is always impeccably fresh, and its batter is as close to perfection as you can get.
But Jim Jack’s certainly holds its own in the company of the region’s best, and I’d argue it’s a worthy contender in the battle for Fife’s top fish and chips.
Similarly, Cromar’s in St Andrews, a favourite of mine for years, is another tough competitor.
While I’d rate it just a bit higher than Jim Jack’s in terms of consistency and flavour, Jim Jack’s offers a compelling alternative for anyone in the Dunfermline area.
Jim Jack’s may not yet hold the title of best in Fife, at least not in the eyes of award panels, but it’s certainly in the conversation.
A new favourite for families
Ultimately, what makes Jim Jack’s stand out is its ability to deliver a satisfying, family-friendly experience with top-notch food.
It’s the kind of place where you can feel right at home, relax, enjoy a hearty meal, and know that the quality will be consistently good.
While it may not yet dethrone the award-winning establishments of Anstruther and St Andrews, Jim Jack’s Fish & Chips is certainly a name to remember – and a trip worth making.
Information
Address: 19 Chalmers Street, Dunfermline KY12 8AT
Tel: 01383 871784
Website: https://www.facebook.com/JimJacksDunfermline/
Disabled access: Yes
Dog-friendly: No
Scores:
Food 4/5
Service 5/5
Surroundings 3/5
Price: £70 for six suppers, kids meal and chips and cheese.
Conversation