It is alleged he purposefully received a booking during a Scottish League Cup game between his current club Elgin City and Hibernian last July.
Prosecutors say this led to a £16,000 payout by online bookmakers Bet365.
The accused men are all from Montrose and appeared on petition, privately and separately, before Sheriff Gregor Murray at Forfar Sheriff Court yesterday.
Hester, 24, Brodie Myers, 26, Calvin Parrott, 24, and Findlay Soutar, 23, face a charge of obtaining money through the formation of a fraudulent scheme.
All four accused made no plea or declaration and were committed for further examination.