A historic Perth monastery faces closure if fund-raising plans are vetoed by Perth and Kinross Council, it has been warned.
St Mary’s Monastery on Kinnoull Hill wanted to sell a parcel of neighbouring land to housebuilders to secure millions of pounds to invest in the 142-year-old building’s interior.
However, a report released yesterday shows the scheme has failed to attract the backing of planning chiefs, who have recommended it be dismissed when it comes before committee next week.
The news will cheer locals infuriated by the prospect of 19 new-build houses on the land owned by the monastery, which provides a spiritual retreat for people from across Scotland.
Despite the Grade B-listed building receiving a major exterior facelift, millions of pounds is required to bring it into line with disability and health and safety regulations.
A Lottery application was turned down and the monastery is haemorraging money after having to install a new heating system.
The partnership with CALA Homes was seen as a last chance to save the landmark building, with £2.4m earmarked for interior renovation and a £1.4m fund for future repairs and maintenance. Although people from across Scotland have backed the plans, Perth residents have not, with 40 objections submitted.ObjectionsPerth Civic Trust and the Kinnoull Hill Woodland Park Group have also objected.
The planning appraisal, to be considered by the development control committee, backs their stance, concluding, “The principle of development on this site is not acceptable as it is located outwith the settlement boundary in an area zoned as an Area of Great Landscape Value.
“In addition, it is felt that the location will fundamentally change the character and appearance of the area, which is an important visual and open space.”
St Mary’s rector, Father Gerald Mulligan, said, “It is with a heavy heart that we contemplate the end of our association with Kinnoull Hill and Perth.
“We had hoped that, following the example of Taymouth Castle, a sensitive development with minimal impact on our setting and improved access to Kinnoull Hill would be possible.
“It is a crushing blow to realise that our entire future is now at risk. I well understand that there are some concerns, but people need to realise there is strong support as well.
“It is a shame that we have been advised that letters of support from outside Perth do not count, but duplicate letters of objection from the same household do count.
“We would urge all elected members to consider carefully the gravity of the crisis we face. The wrong decision will close St Mary’s and end the relief and support we give to so many people in need.”