AN UNLIKELY champion of the Gaelic language the only English councillor in Perth and Kinross stepped forward this week to defend a £330,000 plan to boost the number of local speakers.
Councillor Mike Barnacle spoke out after Councillor Willie Robertson questioned the wisdom of spending such a sum during the current economic climate.
Mr Robertson said that it was with a “heavy heart” that he spoke out over the expenditure on a Gaelic Language Plan (GLP).
He said Gaelic was an important part of Scotland’s heritage and culture in the north west, but not in Perth and Kinross.
“We have heard of the problems we are facing,” said Mr Robertson.
“I have never since 1995, when I became a councillor, been told by constituents that it is very important that we have Gaelic road signs in Kinross-shire, or their children should learn Gaelic in Kinross-shire.
“I am concerned that we are going to be spending a lot of money on this plan when we have so many other concerns.”
Mr Robertson said he would rather the money was spent on diverting young people away from crime, or keeping old people in their homes for as long as possible.
Mr Robertson’s was a lone voice when the plan was debated in the council chamber on Wednesday.
Mr Barnacle said he was the only English representative on the council, but regarded himself as British.
“In Lochearnhead the population spoke mainly Gaelic up until the middle of the 19th century,” he pointed out. “I think it is the history and culture and we have a responsibility to try and preserve.
“I usually agree with Willie (Robertson) on most things, but on this I do not.”
Councillor Kate Howie said she was “saddened” by Mr Robertson’s remarks and said the Gaelic language and culture were strong in her ward.
Councillor Anne Younger said that learning Gaelic helped people learn other languages, an ability which could not be underestimated.
Admitting that he came from a Gaelic background, Councillor Archie MacLellan described it as a “living language”, and said there was a vibrant choir in Perth and Kinross.
“It is part of our culture, tradition and heritage,” he maintained.
Councillor Bob Ellis said he was “slightly disgusted” by Mr Robertson’s stance and that Blairgowrie had benefited greatly from hosting the Mod some years ago, while Councillor Callum Gillies said he thought the language should be mainstreamed.
“If you do not go to a school which teaches it, you do not have much chance,” he said, adding: “Every child should have the opportunity to learn Gaelic.”
The last word fell to Councillor Ian Miller who pointed out that the GLP was something the council was obliged to do.
Perth and Kinross has around 1,700 Gaelic speakers, but it is hoped that the plan could boost that number.
rburdge@thecourier.co.uk